Me: Yes, my unborn but already English-speaking child?
My enwombed little Toner-in-training: Is not our cat Felix the most adorable and affectionate of beasts?
Me: Often, yes.
The kid: Why then do you and my beloved mother so rarely speak of him by his given name, instead referring to him as "the idiot"?
Me: Okay, first of all, just wait till you have siblings. And second, he sleeps in our mail.
We peak early—as newborns, we're the smartest we'll ever be in our lives. Inside those pointy, Winston Churchill-looking heads, our brains are making neural connections so fast that we can actually learn a language without already knowing one. Damn good thing too, since we sure can't fall back on our instincts like the other animals. Partly, of course, that's because "we" in the sense of "people who read and write blogs" weren't raised in the sort of wild environment that would give us cause to develop those instincts; but even so, a horse can pop out of his horse mother and start walking around on his horse legs in a matter of minutes. How is that fair? If Prometheus didn't exist, he'd have to be invented.
Our God-daughter Amy, who's just barely starting to take a wobbly step or two at a time, thinks Felix is wonderful. Whenever she comes over to visit, the sight of him makes her absolutely squeal with glee. (He hasn't let her touch him yet, but we'll get there.) I don't know if a brain-studier (or whatever they're called) would agree with this, but I feel like by the age of one or so, we have a sense that the animals, while kindred, are different from us in some important way. As an expectant dad with a cat, I'd like to have some kind of basic explanation ready for when the kid wants to know why her fluff-clad compatriot isn't coming to church with us.
We see a lot of ugly things in nature. A wolf pack will start eating a deer while it's alive and bleating, grizzly bears casually devour their own children, and there is a thing called a hairworm that enters the brains of crickets and literally makes them kill themselves. Partly, of course, all this is simply because these creatures are natural as opposed to supernatural, and therefore amoral: they're not cruel, they're just hungry. But, also, there's an Enemy roaming the Earth. God always gives us hints of what's coming, and Adam prefigured Christ in a way—a spirit becoming a beast in order (among other things) to raise them up and make them better, to govern them justly and teach them compassion. I don't have a theory on how Adam and Eve would have gotten the carnivores to be nicer to the prey animals, but the Fall put an end to whatever they might have been planning.
But! After the Resurrection at the End of Days, there won't only be a new Heaven. There will be a new Earth, and the animals too will be redeemed and glorified in some way, commensurate with their stature. So when the kid asks me if Felix gets to go to Heaven when he dies, I'm not gonna tell her no. I'm not exactly gonna say yes either, because I think that might be heresy?—although I also think it might be one of those questions that the Church clears her throat and shuffles her feet about. (I'll see your Thomas of Aquino and raise you a Francis of Assisi!) But I will tell her that Felix is, at the very least, a representation of some kind of Ultimate Cat that awaits us in the New Jerusalem, and that Cat will definitely curl up in my kid's lap and purr.